Two nights before his wedding, Tony McCready (Zack Ward) finds himself arm-in-arm with his best friend, and now dance teacher, Harold Lipsig (Kevin P. Kern). Tony objects loudly to the lessons, and when their friends George(Glenn Taranto) and Johnny(Dave Ruby) show up, Tony grabs the chance to cancel the lessons and go to a strip club.

The next night, Harold, George, and Johnny convene at the local bar, Sophie's, waiting for Tony. Harold struggles to write his toast for tomorrow's wedding, while Johnny waits anxiously for the buyer from The Home Shoppers Club who is meeting him here tonight to discuss putting Johnny and his most recent invention on the channel. Between insults toward Johnny about his inventions, George lets it slip that Tony spent last night with a stripper he met at the club. Harold is furious. His friends can't understand it, but Harold has more on his mind than his friend's infidelity.

When Nancy (Kathryn Carner), the bride-to-be, shows up at the bar it is obvious there is a strong connection between her and Harold. But Harold can't bring himself to tell her about Tony's latest indiscretion -- besides, his friends point out, it's none of his business. Things get more complicated when Naomi Latrobe(Tamara Pennington), the stripper Tony spent last night with, arrives looking for Tony, and it becomes Harold's reluctant duty to keep the women apart and protect Nancy's feelings. It's obvious Nancy can tell something is going on and Harold takes her aside, his emotions at the breaking point, and finally tells her he loves her. Nancy is shocked and moved, but tells Harold (as much to convince him as herself) that she loves Tony. Meanwhile, behind her back, Tony arrives and leaves with Naomi.

Harold searches the neighborhood for Tony, determined to confront him. He arrives at Tony's apartment just in time to see Naomi leave. He confronts Tony and what follows is surprising and completely human.

"A Night At Sophie's" is a bittersweet romantic comedy that explores love, success, and what keeps us going day after day. It shows life with its coincidences that conspire against our heroes and dreamers, leading them into their lives with just enough surprises to keep them (and us) off-balance. Will Harold and Nancy find happiness? Will Johnny meet the buyer from The Home Shoppers Club and become rich and famous? Will George ever exchange a kind word with his wife? Is there enough magic in an old song on a jukebox to fan a spark between two people that died years ago?